U.S. Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart’s renowned phrase, “I know it when I see it,” has always resonated with me since my early days in exploration. I was continually impressed by how seasoned professionals could discern subtle details in the data that escaped my notice – a skill honed through years of experience.
The Value of Observation in Geoscience
Geoscience interpretation relies heavily on analogues and models. However, I’ve noticed that observation and careful description are becoming less common, especially among entry-level geoscientists, many of whom are eager to jump directly to interpretation or apply a model they have learned. For example, when examining well logs, cores or outcrops, it’s common to immediately label features as belonging to familiar depositional systems like fluvial channels or deepwater turbidites. In seismic attribute analysis, geologists often seek out recognizable patterns, though geophysicists are quick to point out that what we observe is shaped by complex interactions between sound waves and the anisotropic earth. We have all heard the airport PA system, “many bags look alike.” A correct interpretation is the desired outcome, but it is important to continually test our assessment of the data thoughtfully considering other ideas and continually testing our own interpretation.
Fostering Multiple Perspectives
As a science-based organization, we must continue to cultivate multiple working hypotheses and remain open to alternative interpretations. Too often, technical discussions fall into polarized “schools of thought,” which stifles ongoing dialogue and shifts focus from seeking answers to asserting one’s own correctness. This does not foster dialogue and promote learning. It is something I fear has begun to seep into our discussion. If we only seek out those who agree with us, we miss out on the opportunity to learn something new. I’ve always remembered the advice, “It’s nice to be important, but it’s more important to be nice” – a lesson from my childhood that remains wise today.
The AAPG’s Evolving Role
The AAPG’s diverse membership is a strength we should continue to nurture. Our roots are in petroleum exploration and development, but as an organization, we are engaged with all forms of energy. While the “Petroleum” in our name reflects our history, it need not limit our scope. Instead, it should serve as the collective understanding that guides our future. I see AAPG as a brand, an idea, and an organization that embraces every energy source. As a member-led, science-driven association, we must continue to broaden our perspective and apply our experience in new ways. I am not advocating that we abandon petroleum geoscience – far from it. I believe as an organization we should be more vociferous about the value of our craft, the benefit to society and leverage the vast fund of knowledge to bring new ideas, insight and energy to the world.
The Power of Generalists
David Epstein’s book, “Range: Why Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World,” offers powerful examples of how solutions to seemingly unsolvable problems often come from those outside the field, not subject matter experts. Epstein argues that specialists might struggle to see beyond the confines of their own discipline. We are all familiar with the phrase, “Jack of all trades, master of none.” But that is only the first part of the expression. What follows is rather insightful and, like many time-tested expressions, true. “Jack of all trades, master of none, though oftentimes better than a master of one.”
I believe the U.S. tight oil revolution over the past 15 years has great potential to be mirrored in emerging basins around the world, as global regions draw on the lessons learned by North American operators. What is very clear is that this step-change in our industry was organic and developed by thousands of different and innovative approaches.
Encouraging a Forward-Thinking Geoscience Community
AAPG will remain a society of petroleum geoscientists, but it is important to remember that many members were first drawn to geoscience by factors outside petroleum. Companies will always seek out geoscientists who think critically and approach subsurface analysis from fresh angles. For this reason, I encourage all AAPG members to:
- Promote and foster geoscience study and investigation.
- Embrace our global footprint – encourage collaboration and share insights as an international organization.
- Be “factually complete” in our discussions and approach to energy. (Courtesy of Scott Tinker.)
- Practice active listening and continuously question personal biases – remember, “the modern is the key to the recent.” Petroleum and geoscience paradigms are broken every day.
I want everyone to participate and bring your best to AAPG. Let’s move this organization forward for our children’s children. I am always available through email (brian.horn@hatterasenergy.com), phone or LinkedIn and welcome your thoughts and ideas.