Ready or Not, Changes Will Keep Coming

This table compares conventional exploration plays to unconventional plays.
This table compares conventional exploration plays to unconventional plays.

“My concept of reservoirs has completely changed.”

I actually heard an engineer say these words – last summer, while attending a technical conference of geologists and engineers – and he was referring to the rapidly evolving concepts of reservoirs generated from shale gas reservoir research.

At the time it struck me that it was very unusual for an engineer to say this because, in my experience, engineers are sometimes more resistant to change than geologists.

Thinking of shales (or more correctly, mudstones) as reservoirs, however, is an example of a significant evolution of thinking – a progression also known as a paradigm shift.

For example, geologists of my generation learned that shales can act as source rocks when they contain abundant organic matter and as seals when they cover porous and permeable sandstones or carbonates.

Thinking of a shale as a reservoir, then, is a sometimes-difficult paradigm shift for geologists of my age.

Paradigm shifts occur from time to time – and, clearly, they can profoundly affect how petroleum geologists work. Exploring for gas shales, oily source rocks or tight oil reservoirs is profoundly different than exploring for more conventional reservoirs.

The accompanying table compares conventional exploration plays to unconventional plays – and as the table shows, exploring for shale gas, shale oil or tight oil reservoirs requires a different mindset.

Trap areas can cover many thousands of square miles or square kilometers; permeability is measured in nanodarcys – one billionth of a darcy – and the limit of permeability is determined by the size of the pore throats and the size of the molecules that can flow through them.

Not long ago, petroleum geologists were confronted by another non-geologic paradigm shift – using personal computers to manage and map geologic data. In the years since we first started using them, personal computers allowed petroleum geologists to be much more productive. One geologist now does what it used to require several geologists to do. Today, geologists work with more information and process it much more rapidly.

Some geologists, however, refused to make the transition to using computers to do geology. Those geologists are rare today and probably don’t work in larger companies! Using computers is not absolutely necessary but it is hard to imagine being competitive and surviving without them.

There are other examples: Sequence stratigraphy, for example, was a revolutionary method for interpreting patterns of strata caused by sea level fluctuation and basin tectonics. It created a prodigious lexicon of “seq-speak” – and inevitably left non-adopters in its wake.

To survive and prosper, geologists must evolve along with our science. We need to learn more about source rocks – for example, what is the relationship of pore creation to kerogen maturation.

The investigation of tight rocks is being achieved by technology we need to embrace: pulse decay perm, high resolution CT scanning and ion-milled samples with SEM imagery, for example.

We also need to learn more about completion technology, something that only engineers worried about in the not-too-distant past.

AAPG provides information to help you evolve and you should take advantage of that information. I suggest that during the coming year you consider:

  • Attending an AAPG conference or a Geoscience Technology Workshop.
  • Taking an AAPG school or online training course.
  • Really reading the AAPG BULLETIN or the EXPLORER.
  • Surfing Search and Discovery or AAPG Datapages.

Paradigm shifts require a response from us. We can refuse to learn about them and become extinct, or we can let our concepts and approaches evolve, allowing us to survive and thrive.

Editor's Note: Special thanks to AAPG member John McLeod, senior geologist for SM Energy Company in Tulsa, for his ideas and edits for this column.

Comments (0)


President's Column

President's Column - Ted Beaumont

Edward A. "Ted" Beaumont, AAPG President (2012-13), is an independent consultant with Cimarex Energy.

President's Column

AAPG Presidents offer thoughts and information about their experiences for the Association. 


See Also: Book

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 4384 Book

See Also: DL Abstract

It is quite common for reservoir engineers to adjust the geological modelling without recoursing to the geologists by multiplying the porosity, the permeability, the anisotropy (kv/kh), the relative permeabilities, the well factors and many other parameters within their numerical world.

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3100 DL Abstract

See Also: Energy Policy Blog

The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) methane-hydrate program is making a giant leap forward in 2015 with a new field test. But, why should we care about methane hydrates? First, the world will continue to depend on fossil fuels well past 2040 and natural gas is the cleanest option. Second, some countries that do not have sufficient indigenous energy have potentially large methane hydrate resources. Finally, methane hydrates occur in low concentrations over vast areas of the seafloor and shallow subsea sediments around the world, including the Arctic. If these areas warm, the hydrates could dissociate, releasing methane.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/Field-Experiments-for-Methane-Production-from-Hydrates-hero.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 16112 Energy Policy Blog

See Also: Online e Symposium

This e-symposium provides highlights of the hydraulic fracturing mechanics, analysis, and design, and is derived from a two and one-half (2-1/2) day course which is designed for drilling, completion, production engineers, engineering technicians, geologists, well-site and completion supervisors, and managers, who desire to possess a comprehensive and integral knowledge of Hydraulic Fracturing.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/oc-es-overview-of-hydraulic-fracturing-mechanics-analysis-and-design.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 1475 Online e-Symposium
Business and Economics, Economics, Reserve Estimation, Resource Estimates, Risk Analysis, Development and Operations, Engineering, Conventional Drilling, Coring, Directional Drilling, Infill Drilling, Drive Mechanisms, Production, Depletion Drive, Water Drive, Hydraulic Fracturing, Primary Recovery, Secondary Recovery, Gas Injection, Water Flooding, Tertiary Recovery, Chemical Flooding Processes, Microbial Recovery, Miscible Recovery, Thermal Recovery Processes, Reservoir Characterization, Environmental, Ground Water, Hydrology, Monitoring, Natural Resources, Pollution, Reclamation, Remediation, Remote Sensing, Water Resources, Geochemistry and Basin Modeling, Basin Modeling, Maturation, Migration, Oil and Gas Analysis, Oil Seeps, Petroleum Systems, Source Rock, Thermal History, Geophysics, Direct Hydrocarbon Indicators, Gravity, Magnetic, Seismic, Petrophysics and Well Logs, Carbonates, Sedimentology and Stratigraphy, (Carbonate) Shelf Sand Deposits, Carbonate Platforms, Carbonate Reefs, Dolostones, Clastics, Conventional Sandstones, Deep Sea / Deepwater, Deepwater Turbidites, Eolian Sandstones, Estuarine Deposits, Fluvial Deltaic Systems, High Stand Deposits, Incised Valley Deposits, Lacustrine Deposits, Low Stand Deposits, Marine, Regressive Deposits, Sheet Sand Deposits, Shelf Sand Deposits, Slope, Transgressive Deposits, Evaporites, Lacustrine Deposits, Salt, Sebkha, Sequence Stratigraphy, Structure, Compressional Systems, Extensional Systems, Fold and Thrust Belts, Geomechanics and Fracture Analysis, Salt Tectonics, Structural Analysis (Other), Tectonics (General), Deep Basin Gas, Diagenetic Traps, Fractured Carbonate Reservoirs, Structural Traps, Subsalt Traps, Alternative Resources, Uranium (Nuclear), Coal
Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/oc-es-generic-hero.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 7817 Online e-Symposium