Crisis Creates Shared Ethical Responsibilities

When BP responded to a massive oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico last year, the topic of ethics was among the things bubbling up in discussions.

Rusty Riese
Rusty Riese

Rusty Riese, this year’s AAPG Distinguished Ethics lecturer, had a backstage seat during the crisis as a BP geoscience adviser in alternate energy.

“I thought they (BP) did a wonderful job of explaining and being transparent,” said Riese, who retired from BP and now is an adjunct professor at Rice University in Houston.

The company met its basic responsibilities to clean up the spill and compensate those damaged by the event, he said.

The rancorous public debate surrounding the spill raises other ethical questions, Riese said.

Many parties have ethical responsibilities in times of crisis, he said.

“It’s more than just corporations,” he said. “Regulatory agencies, the public, the courts, legislators and the media all have roles to play.”


In the Deepwater Horizon case, Riese said the media and elected officials seemed especially prone to bending ethical standards and using the situation to their own ends.

For example, the media’s doomsday reporting with pictures of threatened beaches and swamps probably did more to hurt Gulf Coast tourism than the spill itself, he said.

“The horrible wash-over of oil into those areas feared in the beginning never really happened,” Riese said.

Photos of cleanup efforts consistently referred to “devastated” beaches, while interviews with experts invariably focused on worst-case scenarios, he said.

Generating headlines “to suit a 24-hour news cycle ... the media weren’t performing in a really ethical manner,” Riese said.

Lawmakers and other officials likewise “used hyperbole to make points with their constituents,” he said – which meant some legislators “did as much damage as the media” to local tourism.

The public also has responsibilities, if ethical behavior is to be expected from the other parties involved, he said.

“People don’t do a good job of getting themselves informed or analyzing the information they get,” he said.

“They see the petroleum industry as an isolated, stand-alone component of the economy. They fail to see petroleum is just one piece ... of a much broader energy-producing industry,” he said.

“The public doesn’t realize the importance of energy to the lifestyle we enjoy,” he said, “or the scale of the alternatives.”

Natural gas, for example, “is explored for in the same way and by the same people as oil,” he said; wind farms take up huge swathes of countryside, and opponents contend they may endanger birds, mar scenic vistas, interfere with recreation areas and the like.

Needed: More Data

Geologists frequently deal with ethical questions, he said, adding that the most common situation may arise when presenting prospects when there is competition for funding.

“The scientific community does a poor job of providing data for the public,” he said.

Scientists, Riese continued, should inform themselves about the various issues before such crises arise, and should share that information with others.

Setting aside the deliberate torching of Kuwaiti oilfields in the first Gulf War, Deepwater Horizon is stacking up as the worst oil spill on record, he said.

The 1989 Exxon Valdez spill in Alaska isn’t even in the top 10, but was headlined at the time as a pending ecological disaster of epic proportions.

“I was at Prince William Sound (site of the spill) two days ago and the wildlife warden looked happy,” Riese said.

One of the worst spills, the 1978 Amoco Cadiz off France, ultimately dissipated with little intervention and relatively slight impact on the coastal environment, Riese said.

Riese said most of the top 10 spills “self-remediated” or were remediated with some human intervention, and “none seemed to have long-term impact.”

Riese’s traveling presentation, which kicked off at the recent Pacific Section meeting in Anchorage, Alaska, includes a wealth of data that is available for the asking, he said.

Riese hopes to make the information available through AAPG’s website.

After his inaugural ethics talk several people in the audience took away copies of the data on flash drives or by downloads.

“That’s what I would like people to do.”

Comments (0)


See Also: Book

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 4429 Book
Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 4346 Book

See Also: Bulletin Article

Data derived from core and well-logs are essentially one-dimensional and determining eolian system type and likely dimensions and orientation of architectural elements present in subsurface eolian reservoir successions is typically not possible from direct observation alone. This is problematic because accurate predictions of the three-dimensional distribution of interdune and dune-plinth elements that commonly form relatively low-permeability baffles to flow, of net:gross, and of the likely distribution of elements with common porosity-permeability properties at a variety of scales in eolian reservoirs is crucial for effective reservoir characterization.

Direct measurement of a variety of parameters relating to aspects of the architecture of eolian elements preserved as ancient outcropping successions has enabled the establishment of a series of empirical relationships with which to make first-order predictions of a range of architectural parameters from subsurface successions that are not observable directly in core. In many preserved eolian dune successions, the distribution of primary lithofacies types tends to occur in a predictable manner for different types of dune sets, whereby the pattern of distribution of grain-flow, wind-ripple, and grain-fall strata can be related to set architecture, which itself can be related back to original bedform type.

Detailed characterization of individual eolian dune sets and relationships between neighboring dune and interdune elements has been undertaken through outcrop studies of the Permian Cedar Mesa Sandstone and the Jurassic Navajo Sandstone in southern Utah. The style of transition between lithofacies types seen vertically in preserved sets, and therefore measurable in analogous core intervals, enables predictions to be made regarding the relationship between preserved set thickness, individual grain-flow thickness, original bedform dimensional properties (e.g., wavelength and height), the likely proportion of the original bedform that is preserved to form a set, the angle of climb of the system, and the likely along-crest variability of facies distributions in sets generated by the migration of sinuous-crested bedforms. A series of graphical models depict common facies arrangements in bedsets for a suite of dune types and these demonstrate inherent facies variability.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/reconstruction-of-three-dimensional-eolian-dune-architecture.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3249 Bulletin Article

See Also: Energy Policy Blog

Induced seismicity frequently is in the news, especially in Arkansas, Texas, Oklahoma and Ohio, where an increase in the number of earthquakes may be tied to injection wells.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/EPA-Regulation-of-Induced-Seismicity-and-Injection-Wells-2014-07jul-16-hero.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 12906 Energy Policy Blog

Not oil, not shale, but a huge resource! Industry interest in developing oil shale production technology rises and falls with oil prices and the availability of cheaper options. Shale oil in formations like the Bakken is currently more economically attractive and less risky. Chevron, Shell and Exxon-Mobil have ended their oil shale projects in the past year, but Red Leaf Resources is moving ahead.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/oil-shale-may-almost-be-commercial-or-not-2014-01jan.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 12372 Energy Policy Blog