Division Column: EMD

Shale: An Evolution, Not a Revolution

Scott Tinker, speaking at the EMD luncheon in Houston.
Scott Tinker, speaking at the EMD luncheon in Houston.

When you need in-depth, science-based information on shale plays and issues, AAPG past president Scott Tinker has the reputation as the go-to guy.

He played that role again at the recent AAPG Annual Convention and Exhibition in Houston.

Tinker was a high profile presence at the ACE in Houston, where he chaired a forum focused in large part on hydraulic fracturing and was the featured speaker at the EMD luncheon talking about, of course, shale.

For starters he emphasized that the relatively new shale phenomenon is not a revolution as it’s usually tagged.

“It’s an evolution, although pretty quick,” he said. “The technology, demand, creativity, risk – the things we’ve always had in this business – drove this evolution.”

Attesting to its impact, Tinker noted humorously: “In the 1980s, if you cored a shale, you got fired; in 2010 if you didn’t core a shale, you got fired.”

Tinker is the Texas state geologist and also professor, Edwin Allday endowed chair in subsurface geology, at the Jackson School of geosciences, University of Texas at Austin.

He’s also a movie star of sorts, having appeared in theatrically released energy related films. The latest is the award-winning “Switch,” which he conceived and guided through the production process.

It’s widely known that the legendary George Mitchell and his company team spent 17 years doggedly pursuing the needed technology to economically produce the now-famous Barnett Shale. Their ultimate success is widely recognized as the harbinger of the current “shale boom.”

The Barnett, along with the Haynesville, Fayetteville and Marcellus shale plays are included in a four-basin study of shale gas reserves funded by the Alfred P. Sloan foundation and conducted by the Bureau of Economic Geology on Tinker’s turf at the University of Texas at Austin.

The study showed that the Barnett itself is an enormous resource with huge potential, even at somewhat low prices.

In the base case using $4 gas, the assessment forecasts a cumulative 44 TCF of recoverable reserves from the Barnett through 2050 based on already-drilled wells and wells to be drilled through 2030.

The Fayetteville assessment, which followed the same methodology as the Barnett, integrating engineering, geology and economics, estimated technically recoverable gas reserves of 38 TCF for the region. Eighteen TCF reportedly will be economically feasible to recover at $4/mcf.

“There’s a lot of natural gas in the world, a lot of shale gas and tight gas here,” Tinker noted. “As a result of this shale evolution, the price of gas in the United States is about $4, but in the rest of the world it’s $10, $12, $16.”

Implications and Considerations

Tinker pondered aloud during his luncheon talk as to how long this still-evolving action will last.

After all, there is plenty of anger in some corners of the United States, and elsewhere around the world, about a number of issues associated with shale drilling. Hydraulic fracturing no doubt is the largest of the perceived threats in the public domain.

A relatively new concern is the now-unusual flaring of natural gas in oil/liquids-rich plays, particularly the Bakken in North Dakota and the Eagle Ford in Texas.

“Flaring gas – didn’t we quit doing that last century?” Tinker asked. “It’s coming at us like a train, and we need to figure out what to do with this gas.

“It’s energy, it’s methane emissions, it’s CO2,” he noted. “We can fix this; there are a lot of options for using this gas.”

There’s a substantial amount of work awaiting, judging from Tinker’s to-do list.

Much of it is environmental-related.

Environmental implications include:

  • Traffic/noise/light.
  • Land.
  • Earthquakes.
  • Water.
  • NORM.
  • Methane and carbon.

He noted that security issues come into play as well – and the two aren’t mutually exclusive.

Regulatory considerations include:

  • Mandatory baseline data.
  • Cement all gas producing zones.
  • Minimize fresh water use on the front end.
  • Full disclosure of chemicals.
  • Handle flowback and produced water (treat and reuse; dispose – characterize for faults).
  • Minimize methane emissions.
  • Minimize surface impact.
  • Horizontals minimize the number of well pads.
Scott Tinker talking about shale proved to be a big draw for the EMD in Houston.
Scott Tinker talking about shale proved to be a big draw for the EMD in Houston.
A Different Conversation?

Amidst all the frequent hubbub of shale-angst emanating from a number of sources is an unspoken, yet profound, basic fact in the overall energy picture.

“Most people don’t know how electricity or gas are made,” Tinker noted. “And they likely don’t care.

“The public is free not to like everything, but this means we must take the energy conversation to a different place,” he said.

“The conversation we need to have is about the things that energy provides to the world,” he emphasized.

Speaking about the world, a question arose from a luncheon attendee: “Do shales stop at the modern coastlines?”

If you get a handle on how to economically drill and develop shale plays offshore, say goodbye to any financial worries you might have.

Comments (0)


Division Column-EMD

The Energy Minerals Division (EMD), a division of AAPG, is dedicated to addressing the special concerns of energy resource geologists working with energy resources other than conventional oil and gas, providing a vehicle to keep abreast of the latest developments in the geosciences and associated technology. EMD works in concert with the Division of Environmental Geosciences to serve energy resource and environmental geologists.

View column archives

See Also: Bulletin Article

Organic-carbon–rich shales of the lower Marcellus Formation were deposited at the toe and basinward of a prograding clinothem associated with a Mahantango Formation delta complex centered near Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. Distribution of these organic-carbon–rich shales was influenced by shifts in the delta complex driven by changes in rates of accommodation creation and by a topographically high carbonate bank that formed along the Findlay-Algonquin arch during deposition of the Onondaga Formation. Specifically, we interpret the Union Springs member (Shamokin Member of the Marcellus Formation) and the Onondaga Formation as comprising a single third-order depositional sequence. The Onondaga Formation was deposited in the lowstand to transgressive systems tract, and the Union Springs member was deposited in the transgressive, highstand, and falling-stage systems tract. The regional extent of parasequences, systems tracts, and the interpreted depositional sequence suggest that base-level fluctuations were primarily caused by allogenic forcing—eustasy, climate, or regional thermal uplift or subsidence—instead of basement fault reactivation as argued by previous workers. Paleowater depths in the region of Marcellus Formation black mudrock accumulation were at least 330 ft (100 m) as estimated by differences in strata thickness between the northwestern carbonate bank and basinal facies to the southeast. Geochemical analysis indicates anoxic to euxinic bottom-water conditions. These conditions were supported by a deep, stratified basin with a lack of circulation.
Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/sequence-stratigrapy-and-depositional-environments-of.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 7963 Bulletin Article

See Also: DL Abstract

Information on fractured reservoirs is often controversial. Engineers see lost circulation, negative skin and fracture well test signatures. Geologists see only matrix properties in their cores.

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3099 DL Abstract

Human kidney stone formation (nephrolithiasis) presently affects 12% of men and 5% of women in the United States, generating an estimated annual healthcare cost of $2.1 billion. A first of its kind analysis is being untaken of the integrated role of human microorganisms (the microbiome) in influencing the dynamics of human disease-related mineral precipitation (biomineralization). Direct comparison and inference is being drawn from geobiological studies of microbe-water-rock interactions in Yellowstone hot-springs, Caribbean coral reefs and Roman aqueducts.

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 11398 DL Abstract

See Also: Learn! Blog

Discover the basic fundamentals of structural geology, the response of natural materials to deformation, and what changes occur due to the application of stress and or strain energy. Practical Geomechanics will be covering the many aspects of exploration, assessment and production phases of petroleum reservoir development.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/ec-fec-practical-geomechanics-regional-stress-and-reservoir-geomechanics.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 13017 Learn! Blog

See Also: Online e Symposium

This talk will present a brief overview of proppants followed by a comprehensive discussion of the major considerations that are driving proppant selection in these plays.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/oc-es-proppant-selection-drivers-in-unconventional-resources.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 1493 Online e-Symposium