Tuning Effects’ Impact on Seismic

Contributors: Gwang Lee, Keumsuk Lee, Han Kim

Seismic reflection amplitude can be related to net pay and can provide information about the presence or absence of hydrocarbons in a reservoir interval.

Information extracted from reflection amplitudes, however, becomes ambiguous when there are two or more closely spaced reflectors, because reflections from these interfaces interfere constructively or destructively, depending on the time delays between successive reflection events and the shape of the illuminating wavelet.

The variation in the shape of a reflection wavelet created by closely spaced reflecting interfaces is called tuning effect.

When reflection times are measured along the peaks, troughs or zero crossings of seismic traces, tuning effects make it difficult to measure accurate arrival times of individual reflection events.

The thinnest interval over which a correct measurement of the distance between two closely spaced reflectors can be made is called the tuning thickness. The edges of reservoir bodies are often thinner than tuning thickness, and therefore a special approach – such as spectral decomposition or inversion – is required to reliably determine reservoir boundaries.

We examine the tuning effect for a low-impedance wedge (figure 1) that mimics a gas-sand layer embedded in shale. The wedge is illuminated by zero-phase and minimum-phase Ormsby wavelets that have identical frequency spectra (figure 2).

Figure 3a shows the synthetic seismic section when the wedge is illuminated by a zero-phase Ormsby wavelet. The lateral dimension of the wedge in units of the dominant wavelength (λ= 97 m) of the illuminating wavelet is marked on the top of the section. The top and base of the wedge (green horizons) were picked by snapping to the central trough and central peak, respectively.

The thickness estimate and amplitude tuning curves measured from the seismic response are shown as figures 3b and 3c, respectively. Labels are added to these curves to indicate the thickness of the wedge in units of the dominant wavelength.

Trough-to-peak time measurements (figure 3b) give the correct wedge thicknesses when the thickness is greater than about λ/5 (19 m), although side lobes produce minor errors when thickness is near this tuning value.

This tuning thickness is less than the Rayleigh resolution limit (λ/4), which is commonly accepted as the threshold for vertical resolution.

When the wedge is thinner than the tuning thickness, the top and bottom reflections are pushed apart and cause arrival times to be slightly too early for the top of the wedge and slightly too late for the bottom. Thus the measured thickness is greater than the true thickness when the wedge thins to less than λ/5.

The threshold thickness above which the measured amplitude (figure 3c) gives the correct reflectivity of the top of the wedge is about 5λ/8 (60 m). For wedge thicknesses less than 5λ/8, the amplitude tuning curve is characterized by two maxima at about λ/5 (19 m) and about λ/2 (45 m). These maxima occur when the central trough of the top reflection aligns first with the leading negative side lobe of the wavelet from the bottom interface and then with the trailing negative side lobe.

As the wedge thins to less than λ/5, the amplitude decreases rapidly, reaching about –0.02, which is approximately only 10 percent of the correct reflectivity.

Figure 4a shows the synthetic seismic section when the wedge model is illuminated by the minimum-phase wavelet. The top and base of the wedge (yellow horizons) were picked by snapping to the leading zero amplitudes of the trough and the peak, respectively. Manual picking was used for the base of the wedge where snap picking became erratic due to tuning effect.

The top and base of the wedge (green horizons) also were picked by snapping to the leading trough and leading peak, respectively. The thickness estimate and amplitude tuning curves are shown on figures 4b and 4c, respectively.

The thickness tuning curves from zero-amplitude picking (dashed blue line, figure 4c) and from the trough/peak picking (green line) both give the correct thickness until the wedge thins to about 21 m (slightly less than λ/4).

The measured amplitude of the leading trough along the top of the wedge gives the correct reflectivity of the sand/shale interface until the wedge thins to approximately λ/8, slightly larger than one-half of the Rayleigh resolution (figure 4c).

There are no amplitude maxima as exhibited by the zero-phase wavelet (figure 3c), because the leading peak from the bottom reflection does not constructively interfere with the leading trough of the top reflection event.

The amplitude again decreases rapidly below the threshold thickness, reaching about –0.02.

Our synthetic modeling shows:

  • Tuning thicknesses for both zero-phase and minimum-phase data are slightly less than the Rayleigh resolution limit.
  • Event amplitudes can be better measured from minimum-phase data than from zero-phase data.
  • Amplitude detuning is probably not required for minimum-phase data for bed thicknesses greater than about one-half of the Rayleigh resolution limit.

Because event amplitudes in zero-phase data are significantly affected by tuning, amplitude interpretations based on zero-phase data should be calibrated or detuned for correct amplitude analysis.

Comments (0)


Geophysical Corner

The Geophysical Corner is a regular column in the EXPLORER that features geophysical case studies, techniques and application to the petroleum industry.


About the Authors

AAPG member Gwang Lee is with Pukyong National University.

AAPG member Keumsuk Lee is with Korea National Oil Corp.

Han Kim is with the Korea Ocean Research and Development Institute.

See Also: Bulletin Article

The McMurray Formation of northern Alberta in Canada contains multiscale complex geologic features that were partially formed in a fluvial-estuarine depositional environment. The inclined heterolithic strata deposited as part of fluvial point bars contain continuous centimeter-scale features that are important for flow characterization of steam-assisted gravity drainage processes. These channels are common, extensive, and imbricated over many square kilometers. Modeling the detailed facies in such depositional systems requires a methodology that reflects heterogeneity over many scales. This article presents an object-based facies modeling technique that (1) reproduces the geometry of multiscale geologic architectural elements seen in the McMurray Formation outcrops and (2) provides a grid-free framework that models these geologic objects without relating them to a grid system. The grid-free object-based modeling can be applied to any depositional environment and allows for the complete preservation of architectural information for consistent application to any gridding scheme, local grid refinements, downscaling, upscaling, drape surface, locally variable azimuths, property trend modeling, and flexible model interaction and manipulation. Features millimeters thick or kilometers in extent are represented very efficiently in the same model.
Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/improved-geostatistical-models-of-inclined-heterolithic.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3773 Bulletin Article

See Also: CD DVD

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 4109 CD-DVD

See Also: DL Abstract

In 2010 Senator Bingaman of New Mexico requested that Department of Energy Secretary Steven Chu engage the National Research Council (NRC), the operating arm of the National Academy of Sciences and National Academy of Engineering, to form an ad hoc committee to examine the topic of “Induced Seismicity Potential in Energy Technologies.”

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3075 DL Abstract

See Also: Online Traditional Course

This course will help you turn challenges into opportunities as you learn to strategically manage technological innovation, financial turmoil, a changing workforce, unpredictable social media, and tight deadlines.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/oc-toc-leadership-and-strategic-thinking-in-the-oil-gas-industry.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 1487 Online Traditional Course

See Also: Workshop

This is the first of three Basin Mastery workshops provided by AAPG Europe and PESGB at the PESGB headquarters in Croydon. The course aims to take delegates from basin-to-play-to-prospect though a detailed exploration history and specific areas of expertise including structural geology and petroleum systems. This first workshop focuses on Myanmar and Rakhine basin.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/er-gtw-basin-mastery-17Nov2015-hero.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 21835 Workshop