AAPG Adds Voice to Moratorium Conversation

As oil spilled from the Macondo well into the Gulf of Mexico in the days following the Deepwater Horizon drill rig explosion, the White House scrambled to respond. President Obama ordered the Department of the Interior to conduct a safety review of offshore operations and report back within 30 days. In the interim, Interior Secretary Ken Salazar announced the department would not issue new deepwater drilling permits.

The 30-day review, delivered May 27, recommended specific measures to increase safety and enhance oversight of offshore operations. These measures were codified and communicated to industry through two “Notices to Lessees and Operators” (NTL No. 2010-N05 and -N06).

The president simultaneously extended the suspension on deepwater drilling – defined as wells in more than 500 feet of water – until Nov. 30, while the National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill and Offshore Drilling investigated.

The move drew criticism from both industry and political leaders.

Hornbeck Offshore Services, which supports deepwater and ultra-deepwater drilling and operations, filed suit against Salazar, alleging “the federal government’s imposition of a general moratorium on deepwater drilling for oil in the Gulf of Mexico was imposed contrary to law.”

“[T]he Court is unable to divine or fathom a relationship between the findings [of the 30-day review] and the immense scope of the moratorium,” wrote Judge Martin Feldman of the U.S. District Court Eastern District of Louisiana in his ruling. The moratorium was not in the public interest, the judge concluded, and granted a preliminary injunction against it.

Many Gulf Coast leaders agreed.

“During one of the most challenging economic periods in decades, the last thing we need is to enact public policies that will certainly destroy thousands of existing jobs while preventing the creation of thousands more,” wrote Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal (R) in a letter to President Obama and Secretary Salazar. He urged enforcement of existing regulations and emphasis on safe operations.

Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-Louisiana) acknowledged there is no risk-free energy production, but called on the administration to implement new drilling practices, such as those suggested in the 30-day review report, rather than issue a blanket moratorium.

“I believe that we can demonstrably improve the safety of deepwater drilling without shutting down the Gulf Coast economy for more than six months,” Landrieu said.

In response to the barrage of criticism, both the White House and the Interior Department indicated willingness to consider an earlier lifting of the drilling suspension.

“I remain open to modifying the new deepwater drilling suspensions based on new information,” said Secretary Salazar, “but industry must raise the bar on its practices and answer fundamental questions about deepwater safety, blowout prevention and containment and oil spill response.”

The administration issued a revised moratorium in July, after Judge Feldman’s ruling, focusing on the technical specifications of the drilling operation rather than water depth. And as part of this process, Secretary Salazar instructed Michael Bromwich, director of the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Regulation and Enforcement, to conduct fact-finding meetings across the country on offshore safety and best practice.

Independently, the National Commission is also reviewing the use of moratoria. It asked the Bipartisan Policy Center (BPC), a Washington, D.C., think tank, to assist with the assessment.

BPC in turn invited a diverse group of stakeholders to respond to a questionnaire on aspects of offshore exploration, production and safety practices.

AAPG President David Rensink responded on behalf of the Association, providing geological context, discussing how oil and natural gas operators manage risk and uncertainty, and offering AAPG’s view on the use of moratoria.

“An offshore drilling moratorium is a blunt policy tool that is more destructive than beneficial,” Rensink wrote. “Its high cost has been evident this year, as the moratorium imposed in May exacerbated the already substantial economic harm experienced along the Gulf Coast from this tragic event. Consequently, AAPG believes that future federal plans for spill response preparedness should not include the use of moratoria.”

In its report to the National Commission, BPC stated the moratorium gave government and industry opportunity to review and enhance operational and safety practices. The changes initiated after the 30-day review, together with on-going improvements, should be fully implemented and enforced. If done, this “new regime will provide an adequate margin of safety to responsibly allow the resumption of deep water drilling in the Gulf of Mexico,” the report concluded.

As I write this in early September, it is unclear whether the administration will lift the drilling suspension before Nov. 30. But if the moratorium ended tomorrow, what effect would that have?

Would business resume as if nothing happened?

Former Shell President John Hofmeister appeared on Bloomberg Television on Aug. 30 warning that it could be 1-1/2 to 2 years before a new deepwater well is drilled. He fears that early permits will be challenged in court, leaving the judiciary to decide whether drilling will proceed. And the impact of new regulations could have a chilling effect on offshore E&P activity, resulting in decreased Gulf oil production.

Lifting the moratorium is necessary, but only the first step. There are many policy decisions, from permitting and environmental regulations to taxes, needed to ensure robust domestic oil and natural gas production in the Gulf of Mexico.

These decisions ultimately require public acceptance. According to Rasmussen, public support for offshore drilling ranged from 56 percent to 64 percent this summer, with 53 percent of voters supporting deepwater drilling.

That’s good. Our collective challenge is to educate the public and policy makers about what good policy decisions are.

It’s a discussion we need to have.

Comments (0)


Washington Watch

Washington Watch - David Curtiss

David Curtiss served as the Director of AAPG’s Geoscience and Energy Office in Washington, D.C. from 2008-11.

Washington Watch

Washington Watch - Creties Jenkins

Creties Jenkins is a past president of the EMD.

Washington Watch

Washington Watch - Dan Smith

Dan Smith is chair of the Governance Board.

Washington Watch

Washington Watch - Peter MacKenzie

 Peter MacKenzie is vice chair of the Governance Board. 

Policy Watch

Policy Watch is a monthly column of the EXPLORER written by the director of AAPG's  Geoscience and Energy Office in Washington, D.C. *The first article appeared in February 2006 under the name "Washington Watch" and the column name was changed to "Policy Watch" in January 2013 to broaden the subject matter to a more global view.

View column archives

See Also: Bulletin Article

This article addresses the controls exerted by sedimentologic and diagenetic factors on the preservation and modification of pore-network characteristics (porosity, pore types, sizes, shapes, and distribution) of carbonates belonging to the Bolognano Formation. This formation, exposed at the Majella Mountain, Italy, is composed of Oligocene–Miocene carbonates deposited in middle- to outer-ramp settings. The carbonates consist of (1) grainstones predominantly composed of either larger benthic foraminifera, especially Lepidocyclina, or bryozoans; (2) grainstones to packstones with abundant echinoid plates and spines; and (3) marly wackestones to mudstones with planktonic foraminifera.

The results of this field- and laboratory-based study are consistent with skeletal grain assemblages, grain sizes, sorting, and shapes, all representing the sedimentologic factors responsible for high values of connected primary macroporosity in grainstones deposited on the high-energy, middle to proximal outer ramp. Cementation, responsible for porosity reduction and overall macropore shape and distribution in grainstones to packstones deposited on the intermediate outer ramp, was mainly dependent on the following factors: (1) amount of echinoid plates and spines, (2) grain size, (3) grain sorting and shapes, and (4) clay amount. Differently, in the wackestones to mudstones, laid down on the low-energy, distal outer ramp, matrix is the key sedimentologic factor responsible for low values of scattered macroporosity and dominance of microporosity. The aforementioned results may be useful to improve the prediction of reservoir quality by means of mapping, simulating, and assessing individual carbonate facies with peculiar pore-network characteristics.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/sedimentologic-and-diagenetic-controls-italy.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3706 Bulletin Article

See Also: DL Abstract

This lecture presents a history of sea-level changes focusing on the last 100 Myr. Prior to the Oligocene (ca. 33.5 Ma), the Earth had been a warm, high CO2 Greenhouse world that was largely ice-free back to 260 Ma, though recent evidence suggests that 15-25 m sea-level changes observed may have been caused by growth and decay of small, ephemeral ice sheets. The growth and decay of a continental scale ice sheet in Antarctica caused 50-60 m variations on the 106 yr scale beginning ~33.5 million years ago (Ma).

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 11668 DL Abstract

See Also: Field Seminar

This field seminar offers an excellent opportunity for the students to walk on a variety of modern terrigenous clastic depositional systems while observing sedimentary processes, modern sedimentary structures, and numerous trenches illuminating the three-dimensional architecture of each area.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/fs-Modern-Terrigenous-Clastic-Depositional-Systems.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 13368 Field Seminar

See Also: Learn! Blog

The Society of Independent Professional Earth Scientists (SIPES) would like to invite you to join us in Houston on October 24th, 2014 at the Marathon Oil Building for the SIPES Continuing Education Seminar.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/SIPES-continuing-education-seminar-fig-1.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 12990 Learn! Blog

See Also: Online e Symposium

This e-symposium focuses on methods for predicting connectivity within clastic fluvial systems.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/oc-es-connectivity-in-fluvial-systems.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 1480 Online e-Symposium