Quantitative Curvature Analysis: A Case Study

Contributors: Evan Staples, Kurt Marfurt, Ze’ev Reches

Last month in this space we analyzed the relations of fracture patterns and layer curvature in clay models. This month we examine these relations in a central Oklahoma field developed by Pathfinder Exploration, Norman, Okla.

The dolomitized reservoir is 50-100 feet thick within the Hunton Group of Late Ordovician to Early Devonian age.

The data include a 3-D time-migrated seismic survey of about nine square miles, and 15,622 feet cumulative length of image-logs in seven horizontal wells.

The interpreted image logs (figure 1) of all wells revealed 3,971 fractures, as well as bedding surfaces and fault-zones. The majority of the fractures are sub-vertical to vertical, and their strike orientations are plotted with color-coding of our quality ranking (A to D) based on visual quality and continuity (figure 1, left portion).

Fracture density was binned in 55-foot bins, which are half the size of 110-foot 3-D seismic bins, for comparison between fracture density and seismic attributes. We assumed that lithological and thickness variations within the horizontal wellbores are minimal.

The fracture orientations are fairly scattered, yet three major trends can be recognized (figure 1):

  • A scattered ENE-WSW trend in wells 1, 2, 3 and 4.
  • A scattered ESE-WNW trend in wells 5 and 6.
  • A NNE-SSW trend in well 7.

We test the hypothesis that the fractures formed primarily as tensile fractures due to local curvature (see part 1 of this column in the July EXPLORER), and compare their density to the 3-D seismic curvature.

Figure 2 shows a top Hunton horizon slice through the most-positive curvature volume. The horizontal wells are displayed with color-coded fracture density (fracture number/55-foot length).

Figure 2 (left) displays a few areas of good correlation between high fracture density and high most-positive curvature values (yellow arrows). In the next step (figure 2), the strike direction for high curvature values are plotted with color denoting the direction as shown by the time slice.

The general E-W strike directions of the curvatures appear to correspond with the high fracture densities in wells 3–7 (figure 1). Wells 1 and 2 do not cross areas with curvature zones of E-W strike directions.

To further examine the correlations between fractures and the curvature, we used a workflow for azimuthally-limited weighted average of curvature features from the 2010, 80th Annunal International Meeting of the SEG entitled Seismic attribute illumination of Woodford Shale faults and fractures, Arkoma Basin, Oklahoma, by Guo and Marfurt.

Azimuthal intensity is:

[total strike length] / [total area of the search window]

This technique is similar to fracture intensity calculations in part one, but filters curvature strike direction by azimuth.

We calculated azimuthal intensity in 15-degree sections and correlated them to fracture densities in the image-logs; high correlation exists where “r” approaches unity (table 1). For example, the interpreted fractures in well 3 strike 30-90 degrees (figure 1), and we found high correlation between fracture density and the azimuthal intensity at 45 degrees and 75 degrees, which are within the range of the interpreted fractures.

One should note that these high correlations are localized only in areas of high curvature, and do not exist along the entire wellbore. The other wells, excluding #1, exhibited similar behavior of areas with high fracture density and high curvature, and also had high correlation with one or more trends of azimuthal intensity.

In last month’s (part one) compressional clay experiments we found that a critical magnitude of the curvature is needed to generate tensile fractures – and below this critical curvature there was no correlation between curvature and fractures.

We think that a similar situation occurs in the horizontal wells: areas of high correlation between azimuthal intensities and fracture density also show that most-positive curvature values highly correlate with fracture densities.

To identify the critical curvature magnitude in the present 3-D seismic area, we took the areas of high correlation between azimuthal intensity and fracture density in the wells and computed the curvature ranges for each high correlation interval. We then link them to the fracture density range (table 2).

It appears that the critical magnitude of curvature in the study area is between 8.71x10-3 mi-1 and 2.58x10-2 mi-1 as these ranges of curvature correspond to fracture densities > 0.5 (fracture/feet), suggesting that curvature induced most of these fractures.

Outside this curvature range the fracture densities are too low to be clearly correlated to the curvature.

We thus propose that the azimuthal intensity method can help to identify locations where curvature strike orientations in the subsurface appear to be locally related to fracture density

Our main conclusions are:

Curvature calculations in clay models and the subsurface appear to follow similar patterns.

In clay models, a critical value of curvature is needed to initiate fractures. Fracture density rapidly increases with increasing strain until the saturation point is reached and few new fractures are generated.

Indications for similar behavior were observed in our subsurface analysis of image-logs and seismic data.

Azimuthal-intensity by strike orientation is an effective filter to compare curvature orientation to fracture orientation.

In our study, correlations between curvature azimuthal intensity and fracture density indicated areas where curvature and fracture density are also highly correlated.

The curvature attribute can serve as a better proxy for fracture intensity when compared with horizontal image logs.

However, strain is only one component in fracture generation, with thickness and lithology (estimated by vertical logs, two-way travel time thickness, and seismic impedance inversion) also playing important roles.

Acknowledgements: Thanks to Pathfinder Exploration for providing the data used in this project, and to Schlumberger for providing software for this research at the University of Oklahoma.

Comments (0)


Geophysical Corner

Geophysical Corner - Satinder Chopra
Satinder Chopra, chief geophysicist (reservoir), at Arcis Seismic Solutions, Calgary, Canada, began serving as the editor of the Geophysical Corner column in 2012.

Geophysical Corner

The Geophysical Corner is a regular column in the EXPLORER that features geophysical case studies, techniques and application to the petroleum industry.


Image Gallery

Meet the Authors

Kurt Marfurt
Kurt Marfurt

Evan Staples is with ConocoPhillips in Houston, and Ze’ev Reches and Kurt Marfurt are with the University of Oklahoma in Norman, Okla. All are AAPG members.

See Also: Book

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 4193 Book
Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 4356 Book

See Also: Bulletin Article

We present a method of using fault displacement-distance profiles to distinguish fault-bend, shear fault-bend, and fault-propagation folds, and use these insights to guide balanced and retrodeformable interpretations of these structures. We first describe the displacement profiles associated with different end-member fault-related folding models, then provide examples of structures that are consistent with these model-based predictions. Natural examples are imaged in high-resolution two- and three dimensional seismic reflection data sets from the Niger Delta, Sichuan Basin, Sierras Pampeanas, and Cascadia to record variations in displacement with distance updip along faults (termed displacement-distance profiles). Fault-bend folds exhibit constant displacement along fault segments and changes in displacement associated with bends in faults, shear fault-bend folds demonstrate an increase in displacement through the shearing interval, and fault-propagation folds exhibit decreasing displacement toward the fault tip. More complex structures are then investigated using this method, demonstrating that displacement-distance profiles can be used to provide insight into structures that involve multiple fault-related folding processes or have changed kinematic behavior over time. These interpretations are supported by comparison with the kinematics inferred from the geometry of growth strata overlying these structures. Collectively, these analyses illustrate that the displacement-distance approach can provide valuable insights into the styles of fault-related folding.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/fault-displacement-distance-relationships-as-indicators.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 5770 Bulletin Article

See Also: DL Abstract

Carbonate submarine slopes have a tendency to be steeper than their siliciclastic counterparts, an observation that is generally attributed to microbial binding and early cementation in carbonates. However, careful comparison of gross development, curvature, and angle of dip in similar settings shows surprising similarities between siliciclastic and carbonate slopes. This paper presents examples of the various systems from seismic and outcrop and proposes a workflow that facilitates more systematic and improved prediction of carbonate and siliciclastic depositional systems ahead of drill.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/so-different-yet-so-similar-hero.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 11684 DL Abstract

See Also: Energy Policy Blog

The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) methane-hydrate program is making a giant leap forward in 2015 with a new field test. But, why should we care about methane hydrates? First, the world will continue to depend on fossil fuels well past 2040 and natural gas is the cleanest option. Second, some countries that do not have sufficient indigenous energy have potentially large methane hydrate resources. Finally, methane hydrates occur in low concentrations over vast areas of the seafloor and shallow subsea sediments around the world, including the Arctic. If these areas warm, the hydrates could dissociate, releasing methane.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/Field-Experiments-for-Methane-Production-from-Hydrates-hero.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 16112 Energy Policy Blog