Change – or more of the same?

It’s the Environment, Stupid

The phrase “It’s the economy, stupid,” was made popular by former President Clinton’s campaign strategist James Carville during Clinton’s successful 1992 presidential campaign against George H.W. Bush, and referred to the notion that Clinton was a better choice because Bush had not adequately addressed the economy, which had recently undergone a recession.

Currently, everyone in Washington, D.C., and across the nation is gearing up for the 2012 election cycle. It’s a green energy world we currently live and work in, and regardless of the merits of coal, uranium, geothermal, gas shales – and the list goes on – what we have learned over the years, and notably over the past few years, is that environmental concerns can determine, more often than not, whether our profession and industry is successful or not.

On a large scale, one simply has to refer back to the Deepwater Horizon spill and aftermath, whose repercussions continue to adversely impact the industry, the environment and the economy.

However, it does not take a large spill to make the point that we live in an environmentally conscious world.


In the pursuit of energy, the unconventional and alternative energy resources arena is especially susceptible to what I commonly refer to as environmental drivers.

You may recall a case of enhanced geothermal development in Switzerland in December 2009. Enhanced geothermal essentially relies on hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, to fracture bedrock and then circulates water through the cracks to produce steam, which in turn is utilized to produce electricity. However, by its very nature, fracking can create earthquakes, albeit mostly of small magnitude.

In 2010, litigation was brought against a geologist involved with an enhanced geothermal project for inducing some 30 earthquakes – the largest a magnitude 3.4 – through drilling and injecting pressurized water into rocks five kilometers below the surface. Damage to buildings in the region was estimated at $9 million.

Although acquitted, the enhanced geothermal project was terminated. The Swiss case had significant ramifications, and sent a shot over the bow to those in favor of enhanced geothermal, previously considered a clean and virtually limitless energy source.

In the United States, the Department of Energy had provided more than $100 million for enhanced geothermal. One of the big projects was the AltaRock Energy project in my large backyard called The Geysers, about 160 kilometers north of San Francisco.

The Geysers comprise the largest complex of geothermal power plants in the world, and supply one-fifth of the renewable energy produced in California.

The AltaRock project is – in hindsight, was – President Obama’s first major test to advance geothermal energy generation. The Geysers’ geothermal fields are lined with active faults, and minor earthquakes have been induced by the geothermal operations there.

In December 2009, immediately following the shutdown of the project in Switzerland, AltaRock Energy removed its drill rig and informed the government that the project would be abandoned.

The liabilities associated with the subsurface fracturing of rock present a significant setback in our search for renewable energy – thus the efforts for more renewable energy obviously will be hampered and derailed with these legal setbacks.


Geothermal isn’t the only form of energy under attack. Another recent case centers on whether drilling a natural gas well caused four small earthquakes – none above magnitude 2.8 – in the vicinity of Cleburne, Texas, near Dallas-Fort Worth. It did not help that one of the earthquakes occurred during the meeting of the city council while holding an emergency session to discuss this very topic.

The alleged culprit is either fracking or reinjecting wastewater back into a depleted well, which is what one study found.

What happened in Texas did not stay in Texas, as similar episodes are found in Pennsylvania, New York and other parts of the Northeast, as well as California. Fracking was deemed exempt from federal regulation under the Safe Drinking Water Act, but renewed interest on the impact of fracking on water quality is being re-evaluated by the Environmental Protection Agency and at the state level as well.


Following the Deepwater Horizon incident, the “Ragin’ Cajun” was expounding:

“And it just looks like he’s not involved in this! Man, you have got to get down here and take control of this! ... Put somebody in charge of this and get this thing moving! We’re about to die down here!”

Environmental concerns drive energy policy, and policy drives the conventional, unconventional and alternative energy resources, regardless of the merits. How successful we geoscientists will be in developing a national energy strategy that is reasonable and sound depends on how well we communicate with the public, policy makers and the environmental community at large.

Thus, we have a fundamental decision before us, and in the words of Carville, “Change versus more of the same.”

Comments (0)

 

Division Column-EMD Stephen M. Testa

Stephen M. Testa is EMD President-Elect. He is currently serving as Executive Officer of the California State Mining and Geology Board since August, 2005. Testa is a Past-President of the American Geosciences Institute (AGI), the AIPG and the Los Angeles Basin Geological Society.

Division Column-EMD

The Energy Minerals Division (EMD), a division of AAPG, is dedicated to addressing the special concerns of energy resource geologists working with energy resources other than conventional oil and gas, providing a vehicle to keep abreast of the latest developments in the geosciences and associated technology. EMD works in concert with the Division of Environmental Geosciences to serve energy resource and environmental geologists.

View column archives

See Also: Bulletin Article

Regional variations in thickness and facies of clastic sediments are controlled by geographic location within a foreland basin. Preservation of facies is dependent on the original accommodation space available during deposition and ultimately by tectonic modification of the foreland in its postthrusting stages. The preservation of facies within the foreland basin and during the modification stage affects the kinds of hydrocarbon reservoirs that are present.

This is the case for the Cretaceous Mowry Shale and Frontier Formation and equivalent strata in the Rocky Mountain region of Colorado, Utah, and Wyoming. Biostratigraphically constrained isopach maps of three intervals within these formations provide a control on eustatic variations in sea level, which allow depositional patterns across dip and along strike to be interpreted in terms of relationship to thrust progression and depositional topography.

The most highly subsiding parts of the Rocky Mountain foreland basin, near the fold and thrust belt to the west, typically contain a low number of coarse-grained sandstone channels but limited sandstone reservoirs. However, where subsidence is greater than sediment supply, the foredeep contains stacked deltaic sandstones, coal, and preserved transgressive marine shales in mainly conformable successions. The main exploration play in this area is currently coalbed gas, but the enhanced coal thickness combined with a Mowry marine shale source rock indicates that a low-permeability, basin-centered play may exist somewhere along strike in a deep part of the basin.

In the slower subsiding parts of the foreland basin, marginal marine and fluvial sandstones are amalgamated and compartmentalized by unconformities, providing conditions for the development of stratigraphic and combination traps, especially in areas of repeated reactivation. Areas of medium accommodation in the most distal parts of the foreland contain isolated marginal marine shoreface and deltaic sandstones that were deposited at or near sea level lowstand and were reworked landward by ravinement and longshore currents by storms creating stratigraphic or combination traps enclosed with marine shale seals.

Paleogeographic reconstructions are used to show exploration fairways of the different play types present in the Laramide-modified, Cretaceous foreland basin. Existing oil and gas fields from these plays show a relatively consistent volume of hydrocarbons, which results from the partitioning of facies within the different parts of the foreland basin.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/controls-on-the-deposition-and-preservation.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3743 Bulletin Article

See Also: Digital Download

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 4353 Digital Download

See Also: DL Abstract

Hydrothermal alteration occurs when relatively high-pressure, high-temperature fluids flow up active faults and into permeable formations that underlie sealing shales, or other low permeability strata. This process can and commonly does occur at relatively shallow burial depths of less than a kilometer and in many cases less than 500 meters.

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 11670 DL Abstract

See Also: Industry Meeting

For 21 years, the International Petroleum Environmental Conference (IPEC) has addressed environmental issues, challenges and solutions. It provides professionals from industry and academia unique networking opportunities in seeking solutions to environmental problems of a technical, legal and regulatory nature, which benefits the industry as a whole. The formal program and informal discussions with your colleagues during this conference combine to give you the kind of up-to-date information you have come to expect from a major conference. It includes: Plenary lectures featuring leading experts exploring timely petroleum environmental problems and solutions; Technical sessions; Poster Session and Exhibits
Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/ice-2015-tp05-enviroment-regulations-social-license-hero.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 20542 Industry Meeting

See Also: Learn! Blog

Discover the basic fundamentals of structural geology, the response of natural materials to deformation, and what changes occur due to the application of stress and or strain energy. Practical Geomechanics will be covering the many aspects of exploration, assessment and production phases of petroleum reservoir development.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/ec-fec-practical-geomechanics-regional-stress-and-reservoir-geomechanics.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 13017 Learn! Blog