Director's Corner

Today’s Shale Boom: Nothing Invisible About This Story

Shale continues to dominate the headlines.

Seemingly everywhere I look there is a new cover story or feature article on the “energy renaissance” or “shale revolution” that is transforming global oil and gas markets and handing the United States a sizable geopolitical advantage. Back-to-back issues of the journal Foreign Affairs have covered the subject, and it’s also been featured recently in a special section of Petroleum Economist.

For those of us in and around the oil and gas industry there isn’t a lot of new information in these articles. And while I gain new perspectives as I read these noted experts in foreign affairs and economics, they don’t represent the full picture.

Robert Blackhill of the Council on Foreign Relations and Meghan O’Sullivan of Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government write expansively in the March/April edition of Foreign Affairs of the “geopolitical consequences of the shale revolution.”

Their thesis is that new U.S. crude supplies flowing into global markets may well lower prices, thereby limiting the influence (and coffers) of major producers, shifting the balance of energy power and conferring the benefits of those lower prices to consumer nations.

“Ever since 1971, when U.S. oil production peaked, energy has been construed as a strategic liability for the country, with its ever-growing thirst for reasonably priced fossil fuels sometimes necessitating incongruous alliances and complex obligations abroad,” they write. “But that logic has been upended, and the newly unlocked energy is set to boost the U.S. economy and grant Washington newfound leverage around the world.”

Well, maybe.


The cover of the May/June Foreign Affairs features a dark fractured rock surface with orange flames shooting out of the fissures and the title, “Big Fracking Deal: Shale and the Future of Energy.”

In this issue the head of Citi’s global commodities research, Edward Morse, extols the virtues of shale both for the United States and the globe, seeing production increasing, production costs decreasing and overall prices declining to deliver a boon to energy consumers.

Outside the United States, he says, “there is no longer any doubt about the sheer abundance of this new accessible resource base …”

One reason I believe the policy and economics community is talking about this now is because the trends are observable: U.S. natural gas production, for example, has steadily risen – up 25 percent since 2010, observes Morse. Permits to authorize U.S. LNG exports are dribbling out – slowly, but they are being issued.

These trends are frequently presented as both inevitable and persistent. And innovation and technological advancements are said to easily sweep away any obstacles in our path to realizing the potential of this energy renaissance.

I’m reminded of Adam Smith’s “Invisible Hand” guiding and directing the markets. And that makes me uneasy, because it does not reflect the daily concerns I hear about as I talk to our members: the challenges of escalating costs, hydraulic fracturing programs that don’t perform as expected and the continual pressure to replace reserves.

And that is what makes the essay in the same issue of Foreign Affairs by AAPG member Robert A. Hefner III so welcome.

A decade ago U.S. oil and gas production was a shadow of what it is today; certainly no one was talking about a renaissance or revolution. And as Hefner explains, the story of shale is a story of the triumph of the little guy – the small independent oil and gas operator who had the fortune to be operating in the United States.

He correctly observes that the success of shale production in the United States is the result of several factors, including:

  • Favorable geology.
  • Innovative thinking and ideas.
  • Demand for the product.
  • An entrepreneurial culture among independent operators.
  • Property rights that give both producers and mineral rights owners incentive to find and produce these resources.

Pursuing shale resources in the United States was not the result of a policy decision. It was the result of having a system in place that rewards initiative and encourages individuals to put capital at risk in the pursuit of economic gains.

In fact, Hefner warns politicians against tinkering with a system that is already working.


The folks in capitals across this globe listen to and rely on experts, such as those writing in Foreign Affairs and similar publications. They’re smart and have important perspectives to share. But they need our help to understand the realities beneath the trends that they are measuring and reporting.

Shale is transforming the energy sector, bringing new oil and natural gas to consumers worldwide.

But it wasn’t an invisible hand that found those resources and produced them. It was a hand swinging a rock hammer, a hand connected to a brain interpreting a well log or seismic section, and a hand gripping a pipe wrench operating in a system that rewarded that activity.

Comments (0)

 

Director's Corner

Director's Corner - David Curtiss

David Curtiss is an AAPG member and was named AAPG Executive Director in August 2011. He was previously Director of the AAPG GEO-DC Office in Washington D.C.

The Director's Corner covers Association news and industry events from the worldview perspective of the AAPG Executive Director.

View column archives

See Also: Bulletin Article

The Sierra Diablo Mountains of west Texas contain world-class exposures of Lower Permian (Leonardian) platform carbonates. As such, these outcrops offer key insights into the products of carbonate deposition in the transitional icehouse to greenhouse setting of the early to middle Permian that are available in few other places. They also afford an excellent basis for examining how styles of facies and sequence development vary between inner and outer platform settings.

We collected detailed data on the facies composition and architecture of lower Leonardian high-frequency cycles and sequences from outcrops that provide more than 2 mi (3 km) of continuous exposure. We used these data to define facies stacking patterns along depositional dip across the platform in both low- and high-accommodation settings and to document how these patterns vary systematically among and within sequences.

Like icehouse and waning icehouse successions elsewhere, Leonardian platform deposits are highly cyclic; cycles dominantly comprise aggradational upward-shallowing facies successions that vary according to accommodation setting. Cycles stack into longer duration high-frequency sequences (HFSs) that exhibit systematic variations in facies and cycle architectures. Unlike cycles, HFSs can comprise symmetrical upward-shallowing or upward-deepening facies stacks. High-frequency sequences are not readily definable from one-dimensional stratigraphic sections but require dip-parallel two-dimensional sections and, in most cases, HFS boundaries are best defined in middle platform settings where facies contrast and offset are greatest. These studies demonstrate that HFSs are the dominant architectural element in many platform systems. As such, the lessons learned from these remarkable outcrops provide a sound basis for understanding and modeling carbonate facies architecture in other carbonate-platform successions, especially those of the middle to upper Permian.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/outcrop-based-characterization-leonardian.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3661 Bulletin Article

See Also: CD DVD

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3932 CD-DVD
Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3935 CD-DVD

See Also: Learn! Blog

Recent announcements have positioned the Springer Shale as a potentially prolific producer at 12,500 ft depth, with Continental Resource’s initial tests producing more than 2,000 barrels per day.The Springer, which is a Mississippian-Pennsylvanian boundary zone formation has been an important oil and gas producer in both southern Oklahoma and in the Anadarko Basin.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/AAPG-learn-blog-200x200.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 12284 Learn! Blog

See Also: Map

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 4303 Map