One shale led to another

Marcellus Gave No ‘Big Play’ Hints

American Association of Petroleum Geologists (AAPG)

Shale gas plays in the United States may have become almost commonplace, but they continue to hold on to a respectable amount of their initial wow status.

They’re still the place to be.

This is evidenced in large part by the majors and the overseas-based E&P companies who have scrambled to cut deals with domestic shale players to get in on the action, or even purchase them outright – think ExxonMobil’s announced intent to snap up XTO Energy.

One of the truly Big Daddies of the shale plays is the Middle Devonian Marcellus shale, which trends northeastward from West Virginia into New York with a potentially prospective area of approximately 44,000 square miles, according to AAPG member Bill Zagorski, vice president of geology for the Marcellus shale division at Range Resources.

As of October 2009, more than 3,500 Marcellus wells have been permitted or drilled in the Appalachian Basin since the initial Marcellus discovery occurred in Washington County, Pa., in 2004.

Zagorski noted reserve potential in this geographically extensive play is enormous. Modern estimates range from 50 Tcf to over 500 Tcf, defining the Marcellus as a major world-class hydrocarbon accumulation.

“Reported initial production rates for vertical wells range from 0.100 MMcf/d to over 6 MMcf/d,” he said, “and from 0.300 MMcf/d to more than 24.500 MMcf/d for horizontal completions.

“Key geologic and technical factors defining the Marcellus play are similar to other shale gas plays,” Zagorski noted. “They include thermal maturity, reservoir pressure, pay thickness, porosity, permeability, gas-in-place, natural fracturing, mineralogy, depth, structural style, target landing issues and fracturing capability.”

Surprising Success Story

The Marcellus initially was a teaser, with no hint of becoming a major play.

Just as with other shales, operators were accustomed to getting gas shows while drilling through the dense Marcellus rock on the way to deeper targets. But the shows weren’t considered to be a big deal.

When Range drilled the Renz #1 well in 2003 in Washington County to test deeper horizons, these targets didn’t pan out. The well did have significant gas shows in the Marcellus, which in this case proved to be the harbinger of a major breakthrough in the shale production.

Chalk it up in part to serendipity.

“I went to Houston in 2004 and tagged up with a friend trying to sell an interest in a Floyd Shale prospect in Alabama,” Zagorski said, “and the selling point was the Barnett Shale.

“That’s when a light bulb went off,” he exclaimed. “We had just drilled through the Marcellus and had a big show, and I came back with a recommendation to do a Barnett treatment on the Renz well.

“We put in a large frac in October 2004, and right after that we got some encouraging volumes in rates of gas,” Zagorski said. “It was the first large scale water frac and first decent commercial discovery in the Marcellus – kind of like the play starter for the Marcellus play.”

The key technologies being used in the play are:

  • Horizontal drilling, with length of laterals being very important.
  • Hydraulic fracturing.
  • Three-D seismic.

Zagorski commented that while 3-D is important, the Marcellus doesn’t have as big a geohazard component as in other places. For example, issues in the Barnett such as bottom water are absent.

Comments (0)


What Can I Do?

Add Item

Enter Notes:
* You must be logged in to name and customize your collection.
Recommend Recommend
Printable Version Printable Version Email to a friend Email to a friend

At ACE 2010...

Bill Zagorski
Bill Zagorski

Bill Zagorski, vice president of geology for the Marcellus shale division at Range Resources, will discuss “The Appalachian Marcellus Shale Play – Discovery Thinking, Timing and Technology” in New Orleans as part of this year’s “Discovery Thinking” Forum at the AAPG Annual Convention and Exhibition.

This Discovery Thinking Forum will be the third presentation of the AAPG 100th Anniversary Committee’s program recognizing “100 Who Made a Difference.”

It will be held from 1:25-5 p.m. on Monday, April 12.

The New Orleans forum will feature six invited speakers – each a legendary veteran of the petroleum industry who is renowned for success in exploring for and finding hydrocarbon reserves.

This year’s program focuses on insights derived from hard won experience and discovery thinking behind the hottest “unconventional” resource plays of the Gulf Coast and Eastern sections.

Presenters in addition to Zagorski, and their topics, include:

  • John Amoruso – “East Texas, Deep Bossier Sandstone – Amoruso Field.”
  • Marv Brittenham – “Unconventional Discovery Thinking in Resource Plays: Haynesville Trend, North Louisiana.”
  • Gregg Robertson – “From First Idea to 10 TCF in 10 Months: Discovery of Eagle Ford Shale in the Hawkville Field, LaSalle and McMullen Counties, Texas.”
  • Mike Forrest – “Learning from 40 Years’ Experience Risking Seismic Amplitude Anomaly Prospects.”
  • Dan Smith – “Discovery Thinking Has Led to 70 Years of Continued Exploration and Development at Stella Salt Dome, Plaquemines Parish, Louisiana.”

Co-conveners for the session are Charles Sternbach and Ed Dolly.

See Also: Book

Book Check out these store specials. Check out these store specials. Desktop 7811
Book Check out these store specials. Check out these store specials. Desktop 7810
Book Check out these store specials. Check out these store specials. Desktop 7809