Report Shows Need for Data in Health Debate

The recent National Academies’ Institute of Medicine (IOM) report on its late-April 2012 workshop, “Health Impact Assessment of Shale Gas Extraction,” describes many potential health impacts of shale gas development and identifies the data gaps – especially the lack of baseline health data – that keep scientists from differentiating real from potential health risks.

The workshop was organized by the IOM Roundtable on Environmental Health Sciences, Research and Medicine.

The National Research Council, also part of the National Academies, defines a health impact assessment (HIA) as a systematic, but mostly qualitative, process that uses an array of data sources and analytic methods, and considers input from stakeholders to determine the potential effects of a proposed policy or project on the health of a population.

Aaron Wernham, project director of the Health Impact Project at Pew Charitable Trusts, noted that HIAs are widely used in the oil, natural gas and mining industries, where companies recognize that HIAs protect workers and communities, reduce risk and lower business costs.

Expert Perspectives

The IOM workshop provided observations from many experts, but did not provide recommendations on monitoring and managing the health impacts of shale gas extraction.

The workshop did identify potential risks from: drinking-water contamination, air pollution, climate change from greenhouse gas emissions, noise, changes in land use and community impacts related to an influx of workers, changes in traffic and economic changes to individuals and governments.

In three areas, little-publicized data were presented:

  • Declining ozone levels in the area of Barnett shale development.
  • Unhealthy levels of worker exposure to silica dust and diesel particulates.
  • The volumes of increased truck traffic in shale gas development areas.

Air pollution, ozone in the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

Michael Honeycutt, director of the toxicology division of the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ), reported that ozone was the only criteria pollutant associated with oil and gas activities for which the Dallas-Fort Worth area was in violation.

However, as the number of Barnett shale wells grew from almost zero in the mid-1990s to over 14,000 wells in 2011, ozone levels declined from 106 parts per billion (ppb) in 1995 to 86 ppb in 2010. The area standard for compliance is 85 ppb.

TCEQ continues to regularly monitor emissions using fixed-site, airborne and hand-held monitors and detectors. High readings often reflect faulty equipment that can be quickly repaired.

Worker exposure to silica dust and diesel particulates.

Eric J. Esswein, senior industrial hygienist at the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), reported on worker health data collected through partnerships with five companies – at 11 hydraulic fracturing sites in five states. NIOSH found that 50 percent of the breathing-zone, silica dust samples exceeded the OSHA permissible exposure limit, and 68 percent were greater than the NIOSH recommended exposure limit.

These elevated levels of silica dust were higher than levels suitable for the respirators used by most workers.

NIOSH has recommended equipment changes that can reduce the silica dust levels and worker impacts. NIOSH sampling showed that diesel particulate at well sites also is a likely health hazard.

Increased truck traffic in shale gas development areas.

Timothy Kelsey, professor of agricultural economics and state program leader for Economic and Community Development at Pennsylvania State University, reported that Pennsylvania’s economic experience through March 2012 includes hiring, lower unemployment and higher average wages in Marcellus counties, as well as economic disparities between those profiting from development and those that are not.

His detailed statistics on traffic in Bradford County, Pa., show truck traffic increased more than 10-fold between 2005 and 2010.

Some of the concerns stated in the workshop are now out of date because extraction technology, industry best practices and baseline data collection are rapidly changing.

For example, a peer-reviewed study by N.R. Osborn and others (2011) showing a correlation between methane in drinking water and Marcellus shale wells is cited in this workshop as evidence that hydraulic fracturing results in methane in drinking water – but a more recent, peer-reviewed report by Lisa Molofski and others (Groundwater, May/June 2013) provides evidence that methane in drinking water in some areas of Marcellus shale production does not come from the Marcellus formation, and its occurrence better correlates with topographic and hydrologic features rather than shale gas extraction.

Research Recommendations

Several speakers suggested areas for additional research:

David Carey, director of the Weis Center for Research at Geisinger Health Center, located in the Marcellus shale development area, reported that since 2004 the center has been collecting digital data on hundreds of thousands of patients. This data could be the basis for various analyses of health impacts.

Bernard D. Goldstein, professor emeritus, Department of Environmental and Occupational Health at the Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, noted – several federal and state advisory committees on shale gas development have lacked members from the public health sector and little public health research has come from these committees’ recommendations.

Goldstein stated a need for clinical health data that is tied to location information in order to detect hotspots for further investigation.

Roxana Witter, assistant research professor of Environmental and Occupational Health at the Colorado School of Public Health, recommended pre- and post-development collection of data on sexually transmitted infections, crime and substance abuse – health conditions that tend to rise with rapid population increases.

Witter also recommended collection of data on heart rate, cortisol and C-reactive protein, which are potential markers for stress.

Rob Donnelly, vice president of health for Royal Dutch Shell, recommended that industry create partnerships with affected communities and other stakeholders to define the research questions.

The complete workshop report can be downloaded as a free PDF file or purchased in hard copy at the National Academy of Sciences website.

Comments (0)


Policy Watch

Policy Watch - Edie Allison
Edie Allison began as the Director of the AAPG Geoscience and Energy Office in Washington D.C. in 2012.

Policy Watch

Policy Watch - Aaron Rodriguez

Aaron Rodriguez is the AAPG/AGI spring intern at the American Geosciences Institute. He is a student at Southern Utah University in Cedar City, Utah.

Policy Watch

Policy Watch is a monthly column of the EXPLORER written by the director of AAPG's  Geoscience and Energy Office in Washington, D.C. *The first article appeared in February 2006 under the name "Washington Watch" and the column name was changed to "Policy Watch" in January 2013 to broaden the subject matter to a more global view.

View column archives

See Also: Bulletin Article

Transfer zones in rift basins are classified into convergent, divergent, and synthetic, based on the relative dip directions of adjacent faults within the transfer zone. Experimental models were constructed to determine the geometry, evolution, and fault patterns associated with each of these transfer zones. In addition, basement faults with initially approaching, laterally offset, and overlapping geometries were modeled. The models consisted of two layers, with stiff clay representing basement and soft clay representing the sedimentary cover. Laser scanning and three-dimensional surface modeling were used to determine the map geometry to compare the models with examples of natural structures. The experimental models showed many similarities with conceptual models but also showed more details and a few significant differences. Typically, divergent transfer zones are narrower than convergent transfer zones, for the same initial spacing between basement faults. The differences between the different initial fault configurations (approaching, laterally offset, or overlapping) are the degree of interaction of the secondary faults, the amount of overlap between the fault zones, and in some cases, the width of the transfer zone. The main faults propagate laterally and upward and curve in the direction of dip of the faults, so that the faults curve toward each other in convergent transfer zones, away from each other in divergent transfer zones, and in the same direction in synthetic transfer zones. A primary difference with schematic models is the significant component of extensional fault propagation folding (drape folding), accompanied by secondary faulting within the sedimentary cover, especially in the early stages of fault propagation. Therefore, all three types of transfer zones are characterized by significant folding and related variations in the shapes of structures. The transfer zones are marked by a progressive change in relief from the footwall to the hanging wall, resulting in a saddle-shaped geometry. The hanging walls of the faults are marked by a gentle flexure or rollover into the fault, with the amount of flexure increasing with fault throw away from the fault tip. The geometries and fault patterns of the experimental structures match some of the observations in natural structures and also provide predictive analogs for interpretation of surface and subsurface structures and the delineation of structural traps in rift basins.
Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/Experimental-models-of-transfer-zones-in-rift.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3723 Bulletin Article

See Also: Energy Policy Blog

Comment period is open for the EPA proposed rule that would require CCS, carbon capture and storage. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) proposed rule, "Standards of Performance for Greenhouse Gas Emissions for New Stationary Sources: Electric Utility Generating Units," is open for comment until March 10.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/epa-power-Plant-regs-depend-on-enhanced-oil-recovery-2014-02feb-17.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 12375 Energy Policy Blog

See Also: Online e Symposium

Upon successful completion of this course, you will be able to describe geomechanics in shale reservoirs and discuss differences between plays.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/oc-es-all-shale-gas-reservoirs-are-not-the-same.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 1461 Online e-Symposium

The geochemistry of formation fluids (water and hydrocarbon gases) in the Uinta Basin, Utah, is evaluated at the regional scale based on fluid sampling and compilation of past records.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/oc-es-green-river-shales-geochemical-basin-study.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 1436 Online e-Symposium

See Also: Short Course

Here is an introduction to the tools and techniques that geologists and geophysicists use to locate gas and oil, that drillers use to drill the wells and that petroleum engineers use to test and complete the wells and produce the gas and oil. Exercises throughout the course provide practical experience in well log correlation, contouring, interpretation of surface and subsurface, contoured maps, seismic interpretation, well log interpretation, and decline curve analysis.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/sc-basic-petroleum-geology-for-the-non-geologist.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 13607 Short Course