Compartments Can Challenge Logic

All oil and gas reservoirs are compartmented to some degree.

Lateral barriers to fluid flow sometimes exist because faults disrupt and vertically displace hydrocarbon-bearing units. More common causes of reservoir compartment boundaries are lateral and vertical flow barriers created by depositional processes and post-deposition diagenesis.

In this article, we look at a reservoir compartment analysis done across a fluvial depositional system in South Texas.

The story involves a bit of humor, provides a dose of soberness, and serves as a case history that illustrates the challenges of reservoir characterization.

The Situation

The logs displayed in figure 1 describe some of the sandstone units involved in this study, in which the objective was to develop exploitation strategies across a prolific gas-producing system.

Wells 175 and 202 on this log cross-section were near the center of a planned 3-D seismic survey and were separated by only 200 feet.

Stratigraphers intended to use the logs from these two close-proximity wells to start a reservoir compartment model that could be extended across 3-D seismic image space. They had the options of constructing a reservoir compartment model in which unit A in well 175 connected to only unit B in well 202, or connected to only unit C, or connected to both units B and C.

The Humor

To test which of these three possibilities was correct, pressure tests were done between the two wells:

  • A pressure pulse was applied to the perforations across unit A in well 175.
  • Packers were set in well 202 to isolate unit B.
  • The pressure response in unit B was measured.

The packers were then set to isolate unit C in well 202, the same pressure pulse was again applied in well 175, and the response in well 202 was again recorded.

The test results are displayed as figure 2 – as exhibited by the upper curve of this figure, no pressure variation was observed in either unit B or C.

The stratigraphers claimed the engineers could not do simple pressure-interference tests; the engineers claimed the stratigraphers could not correlate logs.

The outcome of the debate was that the pressure test program was redone.

The result after considerable time and cost was the repeat pressure interference tests produced exactly the same curves shown on figure 2. When these repeat test data confirmed the existence of an interwell compartment boundary between wells 175 and 202, friendly relations were restored to the project team and soberness began to pervade the study effort.

The Reason for Soberness

The possibility of a compartment boundary between wells 175 and 202 was not considered initially because of the close proximity of the wells. It was naively assumed these two wells had to penetrate the same reservoir compartment because they were only 200 feet apart.

However, the pressure test data are compelling evidence that an interwell compartment boundary is present.

If a compartment boundary cannot be recognized with log data spaced only 200 feet apart, how can a compartment boundary be predicted using logs acquired in wells at greater separation distances, which is the common well spacing strategy used in reservoir exploitation?

This sobering thought must be kept in mind when doing reservoir characterization studies.

Applying Seismic Technology

Geophysicists were challenged by their geological and engineering colleagues to image this elusive compartment boundary between wells 175 and 202. The later-to-come 3-D survey had already been designed and contracted to create 110-foot by 110-foot stacking bins, meaning the interwell space of 200 feet would be spanned by less than two image bins (that is, less than two image traces).

Thus, rather than relying on these 110-foot-bin seismic data for the analysis, a vertical seismic profile (VSP) was acquired that allowed the interwell space to be imaged with stacking bins having a width appropriate for resolving fine detail.

The resulting VSP image is displayed as figure 3.

One advantage of VSP imaging is that the distance between image traces can be adjusted to any desired value during data processing to enhance lateral resolution. In this instance the trace separation was arbitrarily set at 25 feet to produce eight image traces between wells 202 and 175, which allowed a more rigorous interpretation of interwell geology than could be achieved by relying on only two images traces from the 110-ft-bin 3-D seismic volumes used in this study.

These VSP data show a significant change in reflection waveshape for the thin-bed interval spanning units A, B and C that begins in the stacking-bin positioned approximately 150 feet (six image traces) away from well 202.

This variation in reflection waveshape, indicated by the highlighted circle, is assumed to mark the compartment boundary between the two wells.

Now when I get engaged in a reservoir characterization study, I look at the photo displayed as figure 4 (left) to keep focused on the complexity of reservoir compartmentalization.

Comments (0)


Geophysical Corner

The Geophysical Corner is a regular column in the EXPLORER that features geophysical case studies, techniques and application to the petroleum industry.


Image Gallery

See Also: Book

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 4344 Book

See Also: Bulletin Article

This article concentrates on the question, Which parameters govern recovery factor (RF) behavior in channelized turbidite reservoirs? The objective is to provide guidelines for the static and dynamic modeling of coarse reservoir-scale models by providing a ranking of the investigated geologic and reservoir engineering parameters based on their relative impact on RF. Once high-importance (H) parameters are understood, then one can incorporate them into static and dynamic models by placing them explicitly into the geologic model. Alternatively, one can choose to represent their effects using effective properties (e.g., pseudorelative permeabilities). More than 1700 flow simulations were performed on geologically realistic three-dimensional sector models at outcrop-scale resolution. Waterflooding, gas injection, and depletion scenarios were simulated for each geologic realization. Geologic and reservoir engineering parameters are grouped based on their impact on RF into H, intermediate-importance (M), and low-importance (L) categories. The results show that, in turbidite channel reservoirs, dynamic performance is governed by architectural parameters such as channel width, net-to-gross, and degree of amalgamation, and parameters that describe the distribution of shale drapes, particularly along the base of channel elements. The conclusions of our study are restricted to light oils and relatively high-permeability channelized turbidite reservoirs. The knowledge developed in our extensive simulation study enables the development of a geologically consistent and efficient dynamic modeling approach. We briefly describe a methodology for generating effective properties at multiple geologic scales, incorporating the effect of channel architecture and reservoir connectivity into fast simulation models.
Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/the-impact-of-fine-scale-turbidite-channel-architecture.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3664 Bulletin Article

See Also: CD DVD

Desktop /Portals/0/images/_site/AAPG-newlogo-vertical-morepadding.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 4484 CD-DVD

See Also: Field Seminar

The Hawkesbury Sandstone is the foundation on which the city of Sydney was built. This trip will allow discussion of the sedimentology and sequence stratigraphy of the Hawkesbury Sandstone by examining outcrops around the scenic Sydney Harbour and in spectacular coastal cliffs in National Parks close to the city. The sandstone displays a wide variety of sedimentary structures combined with superb scenery offering many opportunities for photographers.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/FT5-Tidally-Influenced-Strata-of-the-Hawkesbury-hero.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 19011 Field Seminar

See Also: Online e Symposium

Technical Writing Triage is a condensed course which identifies the key professional and technical writing in today’s workplace, discusses the most common problems/issues, and provides quick, easy-to-implement solutions for producing high-quality, effective communications.

Desktop /Portals/0/PackFlashItemImages/WebReady/oc-es-technical-writing-triage.jpg?width=50&h=50&mode=crop&anchor=middlecenter&quality=90amp;encoder=freeimage&progressive=true 3811 Online e-Symposium